Are Kids Failing Kindergarten or Kindergarten Failing Them?

By Bevin Reinen

What happened to kindergarten?

Is kindergarten the new first grade?

Are kids failing kindergarten or is kindergarten failing them?

pails or sand buckets in sand

Over the past two decades, kindergarten classrooms nationwide have grown increasingly academic as a result of the pressures of high-stakes testing set forth by the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (NCLB).


Contrary to NCLB’s vision, many kindergarteners ​are being left behind.


Kindergarteners are failing kindergarten, and their parents are feeling like failures because their children aren’t performing in accordance with “grade level standards.”


However, today’s kindergarteners are required to do things that many just aren’t developmentally prepared to do. And sadly, preschools are rapidly following suit.


A study through the ​Alliance for Childhood ​explains how kindergarteners are now “under great pressures to meet inappropriate expectations, including academic standards that until recently were reserved for first grade” (Miller & Almon, 2009, p. 11). Kindergarten used to consist mostly of things like dramatic play, outdoor fun, arts and crafts, music, block play, show ‘n tell, sensory play, fine motor activities, naptime, storytime, and promoting pre-reading skills only (such as learning the alphabet).


Now, school days consist mostly of literacy and math instruction or taking/preparing for tests (Miller & Almon, 2009). Kids must sit still for longer periods of time and are being rushed to read. A recent University of Virginia study ​found that the percentage of kindergarten teachers who believe their students should be reading by the close of kindergarten increased from 30 percent in 1998 to 80 percent in 2010 (Bassok, Latham, & Rorem, 2016)​.


And what about play? Play-based learning, unfortunately, is often the first thing to go due to strict schedules and crowded curriculums.

This is not to say that kindergarteners ​shouldn’t be challenged academically. They should be, at levels appropriate to their personal development. In fact, many kindergarteners (usually the ones who had the privilege of attending preschool) ​can keep up with the accelerated rigor. But, at what cost?


The ​American Academy of Pediatrics (2018) believes “​play cannot really be overstated in terms of mitigating stress, improving academic skills, and helping to build the safe, stable, and nurturing relationships that buffer against toxic stress and build social-emotional resilience” (para. 3).


Play and exploration are also woven throughout the 10 National Association for the Education of Young Children’s accreditation standards for identifying high-quality childcare, preschool, and kindergarten​​ programs. And as technology revolutionizes, playtime must take precedence over screen time.


Most teachers want to incorporate more play, but report simply not having the time or support from the administration to do so. They are exhausted from fighting a daily instructional battle that is not fair to them or their students.


Are we doing right by children in expecting them to master more and more objectives at earlier ages so that they can eventually pass a standardized test, all the while robbing them of their childhood right to play?


In short, no.


Some states ​are taking action by passing laws that require recess but let’s continue building the momentum. It will take a unity of effort from all stakeholders to make real change.


Let’s advocate for the health and well-being of our kids to local, state, and national leaders and policymakers, spotlight the developmental research, honor flexibility within the curricula, expand opportunities for high-quality preschooling, and create ample opportunities for play in school, at home, and throughout the community.


And let’s trust in our very hard-working, talented teachers in the trenches, most of whom believe that standardized testing does more harm than good.


We can do better. And our five and six-year-olds deserve better!


*See Let Them Play: Six Strategies to Promote Play for specific ideas for embedding play within the instructional day.


Dr. Bevin Reinen is an educator, blogger, writer, speaker, and consultant who has held numerous leadership positions throughout her 15 years in education. Bevin holds a Bachelor of Arts in English, a Master of Science in Early Childhood Education, and a Doctorate of Education in K-12 Leadership. Bevin was named the 2011 Hampton Roads Magazine Top Teacher Overall and the 2015 Virginia Region II Teacher of the Year. Bevin is National Board Certified as an Early Childhood Generalist and was identified as an emerging leader by both ASCD and NAEYC. Her work appears in numerous print and online publications and she is the proud founder of

The opinions, representations, and statements made within this guest article are those of the author and not of Becker’s School Supplies as a whole. Any copyright remains with the author and any liability with regard to infringement of intellectual property rights remain with them. The company accepts no liability for any errors, omissions or representations.